Playbook: win a question a competitor owns in AI answers

How to take a specific AI answer from a competitor: find out why each engine cites them, close the gap on your page, get onto the sources the engines trust, and prove the change.

Updated 2026-11-21
PlanStarter and up
UsesAbout 5 to 10 checks plus credits
Time2 to 4 weeks elapsed

Step by step

  1. Pick the question #

    Choose a question with buying intent where a competitor keeps being cited, from Prompt Tracking's Rival column or Citation Tracker.

  2. Diagnose #

    Run Why Not Cited? on the question for the per-engine root cause.

  3. Compare the pages #

    Run Citation Gap against the competitor and Passage Citations on your page for the question.

  4. Cover the fan-out #

    Run Fan-Out Mapper on the question and check which sub-queries your page and theirs cover.

  5. Fix the page #

    Rewrite the answer passage answer-first, add the missing sub-topics and specifics, and add the right schema.

  6. Fix the sources #

    Run Off-Site Mention Gap and get included on the pages engines cite that name the competitor.

  7. Measure #

    Use check now in Prompt Tracking after recrawl, then let the monthly checks confirm.

The goal#

One question, one competitor, one measurable win. Doing this well for a single high-value question teaches the pattern you then repeat.

Why the competitor wins#

There are usually three layers, and you need all three:

Citation Gap against the top competitor
Example dataCitation Gap answers why the competitor wins: your citation rate against theirs, the root cause, the priority fix and a three-week plan.
  1. The page. Theirs answers the question more directly, more completely or with better structure. Citation Gap and Passage Citations show this.
  2. The fan-out. Theirs covers the sub-questions the engine searches for. Fan-Out Mapper shows which.
  3. The sources. The list articles, reviews and directories engines read name them, not you. Off-Site Mention Gap finds those pages.

Fixing the page#

  • Put a two-sentence direct answer at the top of the section, using the question's own words.
  • Add a section for every fan-out sub-query they cover and you do not.
  • Add specifics: numbers, prices, named examples, a comparison table.
  • Add the schema type that fits, linked to your Organization.
  • Check the draft in Citation Predictor before publishing.
Citation Predictor result for a draft
Example dataCheck the rewritten page with Citation Predictor before publishing: the readiness score, the three fixes worth the most points, and the AI Overview Google shows for the question today.

Fixing the sources#

Work the off-site list from the source used by the most queries down. A mention in the passage an engine actually reads is worth more than any link.

Proving it#

Track the question in Prompt Tracking. Use check now after the page is recrawled, and record a project note with the date of each change so the trend in SOV History has an explanation.

Share of voice over 30 days
Example dataThe proof: share of voice for the question over 30 days against the competitor, with the share per engine.

Questions

How long until it changes? #
Usually one to four weeks after the page is recrawled. Off-site mentions can take longer.
What if the competitor is a big publisher? #
Win on specifics they do not have: original data, local detail, pricing, examples. And get mentioned on the same sources.

Something here does not match what you see in the app? Tell us and we will fix the guide.